Şener Elçin, a Turkish Cypriot trade unionist and vocal opponent of Türkiye’s presence in Cyprus, recently made inflammatory claims regarding the alleged "disappearance" of Turkish Cypriots through population transfers.

His assertions are not only baseless but also indicative of a deeper political agenda aimed at distorting the historical and contemporary realities of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC). Such rhetoric does more to undermine the legitimate rights of Turkish Cypriots than to foster genuine dialogue or solutions.

Misleading Allegations from Within: Şener Elçin’s Distorted Narrative

Şener Elçin has positioned himself as a prominent critic of Türkiye's role in Northern Cyprus, going so far as to claim that Turkish Cypriots are being systematically "disappeared" through population transfers. This allegation is particularly damaging because it comes from a member of the Turkish Cypriot community, giving it an air of credibility that it does not deserve. 

However, these claims conveniently overlook the broader context of the Cyprus conflict and the historical realities that have shaped the region. Elçin's narrative suggests a deliberate campaign by Türkiye to erase the Turkish Cypriot identity, but this is a gross misrepresentation of the facts. In reality, the presence of Turkish nationals in the TRNC has been a stabilizing force, ensuring the survival and prosperity of the Turkish Cypriot community in the face of external threats.

The Historical Context: A Legacy of Survival

To understand the current demographic dynamics in Northern Cyprus, it is essential to revisit the events leading up to Türkiye’s intervention in 1974. The Turkish Cypriots endured years of persecution, forced displacement, and ethnic cleansing attempts by Greek Cypriots. The violence against Turkish Cypriots from 1963 to 1974, which culminated in the coup orchestrated by the Greek military junta, left nearly 30,000 Turkish Cypriots displaced. They were forced into enclaves that represented a mere fraction of the island’s territory, where they lived under dire conditions, deprived of basic necessities and freedom of movement.

Türkiye’s intervention in 1974 was a direct response to these atrocities. It was a necessary and lawful action under the 1960 Treaty of Guarantee, which was designed to protect the Turkish Cypriot community from further violence and to restore constitutional order on the island. Far from being an act of aggression, Türkiye's intervention was a humanitarian response to a dire situation, one that ultimately prevented the complete annihilation of the Turkish Cypriots.

Misinterpretations of International Law: The Geneva Conventions and Population Transfers

Elçin’s argument appears to rely on a flawed interpretation of international law, particularly the Geneva Conventions, which prohibit forcible population transfers. However, these conventions were established to prevent the forced displacement of people in situations of conflict—something that the Turkish Cypriots themselves suffered at the hands of Greek Cypriots. The voluntary settlement of Turkish nationals in the TRNC is not equivalent to the forcible transfers envisioned by the Geneva Conventions. 

Moreover, these settlements have been driven by economic opportunities, familial ties, and the broader context of Türkiye's legitimate role as a guarantor power. The suggestion that these migrations are part of a campaign to "disappear" Turkish Cypriots is not supported by any credible evidence. Instead, it is a narrative constructed to serve a particular political agenda, one that seeks to undermine the legitimacy of the TRNC and its relationship with Türkiye.

The Real Issues: Displacement and Marginalization of Turkish Cypriots

The true victims of displacement on the island have been the Turkish Cypriots, who were forced from their homes and communities during the intercommunal violence. The destruction of Turkish Cypriot villages, the murder of civilians, and the widespread displacement that occurred before 1974 were part of a concerted effort to achieve Enosis—a union of Cyprus with Greece—at the expense of the Turkish Cypriot population.

In light of this history, Elçin’s focus on the presence of Turkish nationals in the TRNC seems not only misguided but also disingenuous. His failure to acknowledge the suffering of his own community, and the vital role that Türkiye has played in ensuring their survival, reveals a deep-seated bias. By perpetuating the myth of "disappearance," Elçin distracts from the real issues facing Turkish Cypriots today, including the ongoing marginalization and discrimination they face in the Republic of Cyprus.

The Role of Propaganda: Misleading the Turkish Cypriot Community

Elçin’s remarks are part of a broader campaign to delegitimize Türkiye's role in Northern Cyprus and to sow discord within the Turkish Cypriot community. This propaganda seeks to create divisions among Turkish Cypriots, painting Türkiye as an occupier rather than a protector. Such rhetoric is not only harmful but also dangerous, as it undermines the unity and strength of the Turkish Cypriot community at a time when solidarity is most needed.

Moreover, Elçin’s stance aligns closely with the narratives pushed by those who oppose a two-state solution for Cyprus. By casting Türkiye’s presence in Northern Cyprus in a negative light, Elçin and others like him contribute to the perpetuation of the status quo—a status quo that has failed to deliver peace or justice for the Turkish Cypriots. It is essential to recognize that this rhetoric does not serve the interests of the Turkish Cypriot community but rather those who wish to see the TRNC isolated and weakened.

The Need for a Strong, United Front: Defending the Rights of Turkish Cypriots

As the Turkish Cypriot community continues to navigate the complex political landscape of Cyprus, it is crucial to maintain a strong and united front. This means standing up against misinformation and propaganda, whether it comes from external sources or from within the community itself. The rights and future of the Turkish Cypriots must not be compromised by those who seek to advance their own political agendas at the expense of the broader community.

The international community also has a role to play in this. It must recognize the legitimate rights of the Turkish Cypriots and reject any attempts to undermine the sovereignty of the TRNC. This includes holding accountable those who spread false narratives about the situation in Northern Cyprus and ensuring that the voices of the Turkish Cypriots are heard and respected on the global stage.

TCE Conclusion: Reaffirming the Truth

Şener Elçin’s allegations regarding the "disappearance" of Turkish Cypriots through population transfers are not only unfounded but also serve to distract from the real issues that need to be addressed in Cyprus. The Turkish Cypriots have every right to determine their own future, and this right must be defended against those who seek to undermine it through misinformation and propaganda.

As we move forward, it is essential to remember the historical context in which the TRNC was established and the ongoing challenges faced by the Turkish Cypriot community. The road to peace and stability in Cyprus must be paved with truth, not the politically motivated fabrications of those who refuse to accept the reality of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus.

The Turkish Cypriot community, with the support of Türkiye, will continue to assert its right to exist and thrive on the island of Cyprus. No amount of propaganda or historical revisionism can change the fact that the TRNC is a reality, one that is here to stay. It is time for the international community to acknowledge this reality and work towards a solution that respects the rights and aspirations of all Cypriots, both Turkish and Greek.

Please remember to share this article widely with your friends and via social media with your friends.

References:
- Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Türkiye, How Did the Greek Cypriots Persecute the Turks of Cyprus Between 1963-1974? [MFA Türkiye](https://www.mfa.gov.tr).
- Clingendael Institute, Turkey’s Interventions in its Near Abroad: The Case of Northern Cyprus [Clingendael](https://www.clingendael.org/sites/default/files/2022-05/Policy_brief_Turkeys_interventions_Northern_Cyprus.pdf).