The Turkish Cypriot community, long isolated due to the lack of international recognition of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC), is exploring innovative avenues to break economic barriers. With the Commonwealth of Nations being a voluntary association of 56 independent and equal countries, primarily focused on cooperation in trade, education, and development, the question arises: Can Turkish Cypriots leverage this platform to enhance trade without official recognition?

 

The Commonwealth: A Non-Political Platform for Cooperation

The Commonwealth is unique in its non-political stance, fostering cooperation among member states regardless of their political affiliations or disputes. Cyprus, despite its divided status since 1974, is officially a member of the Commonwealth. The organization emphasizes equality, development, and mutual assistance, making it an attractive avenue for economic engagement.

 

According to the Commonwealth Charter, the association is "a voluntary association of independent and equal sovereign states, each responsible for its own policies." It further states that members are "free and equal," and decisions are made through consensus rather than binding treaties.

 

The Turkish Cypriot Predicament

The TRNC declared independence in 1983 but is recognized only by Turkey. This lack of recognition has led to economic embargoes and limited access to international markets. The European Union, of which the Republic of Cyprus is a member, does not extend its acquis communautaire to the northern part of the island, further complicating matters.

 

Dr. Ahmet Sözen, a professor of International Relations at Eastern Mediterranean University, explains: "Turkish Cypriots face economic isolation due to political non-recognition, which hampers trade, education, and overall development."

 

Opportunities within the Commonwealth Framework

Despite these challenges, the Commonwealth's non-political nature offers a potential gateway for Turkish Cypriots to engage in trade and development activities. Since the organization focuses on people-to-people connections and economic cooperation without delving into political recognition issues, there is room for Turkish Cypriot businesses to establish contacts and partnerships.

 

Case Study: The Gambia's Re-Engagement

The Gambia, which left the Commonwealth in 2013 and rejoined in 2018, showcases the organization's flexibility. During its absence, Gambian businesses continued informal trade relations with Commonwealth countries. Upon re-entry, these relations were formalized, boosting the nation's economy.

 

Dr. Catherine Grant Makokera, a trade expert at the Tutwa Consulting Group, notes: "The Commonwealth's emphasis on cooperation over politics allowed The Gambia to reintegrate smoothly, highlighting the organization's potential as a platform for economic engagement."

 

Legal and Practical Challenges

However, engaging with the Commonwealth is not without obstacles for Turkish Cypriots. The primary challenge lies in the lack of official recognition, which complicates formal trade agreements. International law generally requires state recognition for bilateral agreements, and most Commonwealth countries adhere to UN resolutions recognizing only the Republic of Cyprus.

 

Yet, the Commonwealth's focus on civil society and business networks could bypass some of these hurdles. The Commonwealth Enterprise and Investment Council (CWEIC), for instance, works to promote trade and investment across the Commonwealth. Turkish Cypriot businesses could potentially participate in CWEIC events and forums.

 

Potential Mechanisms for Engagement

1. Business Associations and Chambers of Commerce: Turkish Cypriot business groups can seek observer status or associate membership in Commonwealth business councils.

 

2. Academic and Cultural Exchanges: Universities and cultural organizations in Northern Cyprus can establish partnerships with counterparts in Commonwealth countries, promoting education and cultural understanding.

 

3. Leveraging Turkey's Influence: As a strategic partner of several Commonwealth countries, Turkey could facilitate introductions and support Turkish Cypriot initiatives within the Commonwealth framework.

 

Voices from the Turkish Cypriot Community

Hasan Taçoy, former Minister of Economy and Energy in the TRNC, expresses optimism: "We believe that economic isolation can be mitigated through innovative approaches. Engaging with Commonwealth countries on trade and education is a possibility we are keen to explore."

 

Entrepreneurs in Northern Cyprus are particularly interested in sectors like tourism, education, and agriculture—areas where Commonwealth cooperation could be beneficial.

 

International Perspectives

Some Commonwealth countries may be open to informal economic relations with Turkish Cypriots. For instance, countries like the United Kingdom, which has historical ties to the island, could play a mediating role.

 

In a 2014 report by the UK Parliament's Foreign Affairs Committee, it was suggested: "The UK should consider ways to promote the economic development of the Turkish Cypriot community without prejudicing the political situation."

 

The Role of the European Union

The EU's Green Line Regulation allows for the movement of goods across the divide in Cyprus but is limited in scope. However, increased economic activity facilitated by Commonwealth connections could complement EU efforts.

 

"The European Union supports the economic development of the Turkish Cypriot community as a means to facilitate reunification," says Pieter Van Nuffel, former Personal Representative of the President of the European Commission for the Cyprus Settlement.

 

Challenges Ahead

Despite the potential, significant challenges remain:

- Diplomatic Sensitivities: Any move perceived as legitimizing the TRNC could face pushback from the Republic of Cyprus and Greece.

 

- Legal Constraints: Without state recognition, Turkish Cypriot entities may face legal obstacles in international trade.

 

- Political Opposition: Hardliners on both sides may resist initiatives that seem to bypass official channels.

 

A Path Forward

To navigate these challenges, a carefully calibrated approach is necessary:

- Engagement Through Civil Society: Focusing on people-to-people contacts and business-to-business relations can minimize political friction.

 

- Transparency and Communication: Clearly communicating the non-political nature of engagements can alleviate concerns.

 

- Building Trust: Success stories of economic cooperation can build momentum and demonstrate mutual benefits.

 

TCE Conclusion: Is It Achievable?

While official recognition remains elusive, the Turkish Cypriot community has avenues to engage with the Commonwealth's economic and social networks. By leveraging the organization's non-political nature and focusing on mutual interests, Turkish Cypriots can potentially enhance trade, education, and development.

 

"Isolation is not insurmountable," asserts Dr. Ahmet Sözen. "With creativity and determination, we can find pathways to global engagement that benefit all parties involved."

In an increasingly interconnected world, economic cooperation can serve as a bridge over political divides. For the Turkish Cypriots, the Commonwealth may offer a platform to assert their presence on the global stage, fostering growth and perhaps paving the way for a more comprehensive resolution of the island's longstanding divisions.

---

References

- Commonwealth Secretariat. (n.d.). About Us.
- Commonwealth Secretariat. (2013). Charter of the Commonwealth.
- Sözen, A. (2020). Interview with TRT World on the Economic Isolation of Turkish Cypriots.
- Makokera, C. G. (2018). The Gambia's Return to the Commonwealth: Implications for Trade and Development. Tutwa Consulting Group.
- UK Parliament Foreign Affairs Committee. (2014). Sixth Report: The UK's Relations with Cyprus. 
- Van Nuffel, P. (2016). Speech at the Conference on Cyprus Settlement Support. European Commission Archive.
- Taçoy, H. (2019). Address at the Eastern Mediterranean Business Forum. 
- European Union. (2004). Regulation (EC) No 866/2004 (Green Line Regulation).
- Commonwealth Enterprise and Investment Council. (n.d.). Our Work. 
- Eastern Mediterranean University. (2021). Collaborative Projects with Commonwealth Universities.